Image : Bram Lammers

 

By Philip van Ryneveld and Jugal Mahabir

[First published in Sunday Times]

Most large muni­cip­al­it­ies buy elec­tri­city in bulk from Eskom and sell it to con­sumers with a markup that must pay for the muni­cip­al­ity’s own elec­tri­city dis­tri­bu­tion net­works, includ­ing oper­a­tions and main­ten­ance plus equip­ment such as trans­formers and muni­cipal power­lines. His­tor­ic­ally, muni­cip­al­it­ies have gen­er­ated a sur­plus doing this, using it to cross-sub­sid­ise other ser­vices. Elec­tri­city has been the largest single activ­ity on muni­cipal budgets — and the biggest item on a house­hold’s muni­cipal account.

The recently launched local gov­ern­ment white paper iden­ti­fies many crit­ical internal local gov­ern­ment prob­lems, includ­ing poor admin­is­tra­tion and cor­rup­tion, and sets out meas­ures to tackle them.

It also iden­ti­fies key external chal­lenges faced by muni­cipal gov­ern­ments.

Among these, it high­lights the dam­aging impact of high bulk elec­tri­city prices on muni­cipal fin­ances, not­ing that between 2008 and 2025 the price charged by Eskom rose from 18c/kWh to 184c/kWh.

This is a nine­fold increase over a period when gen­eral infla­tion rose only one and a half times, trans­lat­ing into a quad­rupling of the price in real terms (which are price rise minus infla­tion) over the period.

A few more num­bers con­vey the mag­nitude of the increase. Between 2008 and 2025, muni­cip­al­it­ies paid Eskom R1.26-tril­lion, which they covered through the fees they charged cus­tom­ers. Had the bulk elec­tri­city price risen only as fast as infla­tion, they would have needed to pay just R473bn. The dif­fer­ence of R789bn is the because addi­tional of amount that por­tion muni­cip­al­it­ies’have of Eskom s bulk had price to pay rise Eskom that was higher than infla­tion.

Muni­cipal debt to Eskom has been climb­ing at a wor­ry­ing rate, and must be dealt with, but the amount of R789bn is close to eight times the total accu­mu­lated debt of all muni­cip­al­it­ies to Eskom at the end of 2025, which then stood at R94.6bn (R111.6bn at the end of the 2026 fin­an­cial year).

Indeed, the total accu­mu­lated debt of R94.6bn was only 7.5% of the R1.26-tril­lion fig­ure, mean­ing that, taken as a whole, the pay­ment rate of the muni­cipal sec­tor to Eskom was roughly 92.5% over the period, exclud­ing rel­at­ively small debt write-offs.

Had the real cost of elec­tri­city remained at 2008 levels, rising only as fast as infla­tion, muni­cip­al­it­ies would have saved R110bn just on the 2025 bill to Eskom, enough to pay off all the accu­mu­lated debt of all muni­cip­al­it­ies to Eskom.

The sum of R789bn is about equal to the total of all grants, con­di­tional and uncon­di­tional, from the gov­ern­ment to muni­cip­al­it­ies for the six years prior to and includ­ing 2025 and 89% of all prop­erty rates col­lec­ted nation­ally between 2008 and 2025.

The main vic­tims have been house­holds and busi­nesses but muni­cip­al­it­ies have also been squeezed. The white paper notes that in 2008, pay­ment for bulk elec­tri­city and bulk water com­bined was equi­val­ent to just under half of the total com­bined rev­enue col­lec­ted by muni­cip­al­it­ies for all trad­ing ser­vices: elec­tri­city, water, sew­er­age and refuse.

By last year this had risen to nearly three quar­ters, leav­ing just more than a quarter of total ser­vice rev­enue col­lec­ted for muni­cip­al­it­ies to run their own activ­it­ies across all these ser­vices.

First to suf­fer is always main­ten­ance, espe­cially the cap­ital expendit­ure needed to renew and expand net­works. But over time this leads to out­ages, increased water and elec­tri­city losses and other fail­ures, lead­ing to the down­wards spiral that many muni­cip­al­it­ies are now in. The scope for cross-sub­sid­ising other ser­vices from elec­tri­city rev­en­ues is largely gone.

Muni­cip­al­it­ies have much to answer for. The fact that some muni­cip­al­it­ies have been able to man­age these pres­sures reas­on­ably suc­cess­fully points to fail­ures in oth­ers. But now that load-shed­ding is over — partly because high prices reduced demand — most of the blame for poor ser­vices and high prices is dir­ec­ted at muni­cip­al­it­ies. Yet, as these num­bers show, there has been a massive and con­tinu­ing trans­fer of money from con­sumers to Eskom, which muni­cip­al­it­ies have to col­lect.

And the chal­lenge for muni­cip­al­it­ies is that the charges for all their other ser­vices must come out of these same pock­ets. No sur­prise that we are see­ing worsen­ing pay­ment levels across all ser­vices, with large increases in van­dal­ism and elec­tri­city theft.

At the Treas­ury’s request, the white paper puts the ball in its court to find new mech­an­isms to take on these and other chal­lenges. It is not easy.

The good news is that the pres­id­ent has appoin­ted out­stand­ing com­mis­sion­ers to the Fin­an­cial and Fiscal Com­mis­sion (FFC) with former fin­ance min­is­ter Nhlanhla Nene as chair and former Treas­ury deputy dir­ector-gen­eral Malijeng Ngqaleni as deputy. The FFC advises on all fiscal mat­ters rel­ev­ant to decent­ral­isa­tion. It played an import­ant role after 1994 in estab­lish­ing the cur­rent sys­tem but has lost impact since then. It must step for­ward once again.