Image : Bram Lammers
By Philip van Ryneveld and Jugal Mahabir
[First published in Sunday Times]
Most large municipalities buy electricity in bulk from Eskom and sell it to consumers with a markup that must pay for the municipality’s own electricity distribution networks, including operations and maintenance plus equipment such as transformers and municipal powerlines. Historically, municipalities have generated a surplus doing this, using it to cross-subsidise other services. Electricity has been the largest single activity on municipal budgets — and the biggest item on a household’s municipal account.
The recently launched local government white paper identifies many critical internal local government problems, including poor administration and corruption, and sets out measures to tackle them.
It also identifies key external challenges faced by municipal governments.
Among these, it highlights the damaging impact of high bulk electricity prices on municipal finances, noting that between 2008 and 2025 the price charged by Eskom rose from 18c/kWh to 184c/kWh.
This is a ninefold increase over a period when general inflation rose only one and a half times, translating into a quadrupling of the price in real terms (which are price rise minus inflation) over the period.
A few more numbers convey the magnitude of the increase. Between 2008 and 2025, municipalities paid Eskom R1.26-trillion, which they covered through the fees they charged customers. Had the bulk electricity price risen only as fast as inflation, they would have needed to pay just R473bn. The difference of R789bn is the because additional of amount that portion municipalities’have of Eskom s bulk had price to pay rise Eskom that was higher than inflation.
Municipal debt to Eskom has been climbing at a worrying rate, and must be dealt with, but the amount of R789bn is close to eight times the total accumulated debt of all municipalities to Eskom at the end of 2025, which then stood at R94.6bn (R111.6bn at the end of the 2026 financial year).
Indeed, the total accumulated debt of R94.6bn was only 7.5% of the R1.26-trillion figure, meaning that, taken as a whole, the payment rate of the municipal sector to Eskom was roughly 92.5% over the period, excluding relatively small debt write-offs.
Had the real cost of electricity remained at 2008 levels, rising only as fast as inflation, municipalities would have saved R110bn just on the 2025 bill to Eskom, enough to pay off all the accumulated debt of all municipalities to Eskom.
The sum of R789bn is about equal to the total of all grants, conditional and unconditional, from the government to municipalities for the six years prior to and including 2025 and 89% of all property rates collected nationally between 2008 and 2025.
The main victims have been households and businesses but municipalities have also been squeezed. The white paper notes that in 2008, payment for bulk electricity and bulk water combined was equivalent to just under half of the total combined revenue collected by municipalities for all trading services: electricity, water, sewerage and refuse.
By last year this had risen to nearly three quarters, leaving just more than a quarter of total service revenue collected for municipalities to run their own activities across all these services.
First to suffer is always maintenance, especially the capital expenditure needed to renew and expand networks. But over time this leads to outages, increased water and electricity losses and other failures, leading to the downwards spiral that many municipalities are now in. The scope for cross-subsidising other services from electricity revenues is largely gone.
Municipalities have much to answer for. The fact that some municipalities have been able to manage these pressures reasonably successfully points to failures in others. But now that load-shedding is over — partly because high prices reduced demand — most of the blame for poor services and high prices is directed at municipalities. Yet, as these numbers show, there has been a massive and continuing transfer of money from consumers to Eskom, which municipalities have to collect.
And the challenge for municipalities is that the charges for all their other services must come out of these same pockets. No surprise that we are seeing worsening payment levels across all services, with large increases in vandalism and electricity theft.
At the Treasury’s request, the white paper puts the ball in its court to find new mechanisms to take on these and other challenges. It is not easy.
The good news is that the president has appointed outstanding commissioners to the Financial and Fiscal Commission (FFC) with former finance minister Nhlanhla Nene as chair and former Treasury deputy director-general Malijeng Ngqaleni as deputy. The FFC advises on all fiscal matters relevant to decentralisation. It played an important role after 1994 in establishing the current system but has lost impact since then. It must step forward once again.